|
|
Post by Joanna on Apr 9, 2005 14:26:55 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by safyre on Apr 9, 2005 16:12:50 GMT -5
Not sure if just anyone is allowed to reply but I have time so I will.  Images: Main banner makes a good use of color. Blending is good, I like how the horses legs were faded in as apposed to being just left there. Good font choice. You might want to try adding some more custom graphics to make the site shine. Definatly like the textured borders on the layout. Colors: The colors go well together. With the green, dark blue and white. Layout: Its a little jumbled. The hall of fame is too much on the side. I think that is the only reason for the jumbled look. The top is good. Just on smaller resolutions it would be hard with that side bar. Resolution Compatibility: looks good on larger resolutions but doesn't resize well in 800x600. Playability/Activity: There were members actively posting while I was on, which is a good sign. Rules seem easy to understand and were catigorized. I never understood why games restrict the ammount of members though. Font Choice: The fonts are huge on the headers where they are small on the posts. Its a simple fix with a little html. Or use your table script to make it look connected. Overall: If you are using a High Res, it has a good appearence, makes a good first impression, seems active and well run. I give it an 8/10. |
|
|
|
Post by silveroptics on Jun 11, 2005 16:08:23 GMT -5
I'm going to rate on what the admin lady said to.
Layout: It's alright, but it seems a little too done up for my tastes. It looks like the lady who wore a beautiful dress of white feathers and silk, and forgot to do her hair.
Colors: The colors are very nice. I like how they look together. You should have more color though; too much green.
Idea: Your general theme is overdone, but I love the "The Gaia" plot. Its a silly name for a disease though, and I'm going to rag on you about that since I'm an earthie.
Understandability: It's a little confusing when you first enter it, but it works itself out. Work on it being more newcomer friendly.
Overall: 7/10 it was satisfactory. I think you should go through and delete inactive members, because joining a huge forum scares me. I think I'll join though. I doubt that all those members are active.
|
|
Ichor
New
Read it.
Posts: 5
|
Post by Ichor on Jul 5, 2005 13:58:39 GMT -5
Main banner was nice, the whole thing too simple for my tastes. I despise animal role-playing, so I wouldn't join by any means. Four out of ten.
|
|
